Evaluation Ethics for Best Practice
Cases and Commentaries
Edited by Michael Morris
2. The Entry/Contracting Stage
Scenario 1: The Coordination Project
Commentary: Consumers, Culture, and Validity, Karen E. Kirkhart
Commentary: Whose Evaluation Is It, Anyway?, David M. Chavis
What If...?
Final Thoughts: The Coordination Project
Scenario 2: Just Say No?
Questions to Consider
3. Designing the Evaluation
Scenario 1: The Damp Parade?
Commentary: Everybody Talks about the Weather..., Melvin M. Mark
Commentary: No Rain Today, Gail V. Barrington
What If...?
Final Thoughts: The Damp Parade
Scenario 2: What’s under the Rock?
Questions to Consider
4. Data Collection
Scenario 1: The Folder
Commentary: Hold ’Em or Fold(er) ’Em?: What’s an Evaluator to Do?, Michael Hendricks
Commentary: Centering the Folder, sarita davis
What If…..?
Final Thoughts: The Folder
Scenario 2: Hideout
Questions to Consider
5. Data Analysis and Interpretation
Scenario 1: Knock, Knock, What’s There?
Commentary: What’s There: Confidence or Competence?, Leslie J. Cooksy
Commentary: Interpreting Effects, William R. Shadish
What If...?
Final Thoughts: Knock, Knock, What’s There?
Scenario 2: Things Happen
Questions to Consider
6. Communication of Results
Scenario 1: Mainstream
Commentary: Mainstreaming Process Evaluation: Ethical Issues in Reporting Interim Results, Mary Ann Scheirer
Commentary: Reporting Bad News: Challenges and Opportunities in an Ethical Dilemma, Yolanda Suarez-Balcazar and Lucía Orellana-Damacela
What If...?
Final Thoughts: Mainstream
Scenario 2: Whose Voices?
Questions to Consider
7. Utilization of Results
Scenario 1: Nightly News
Commentary: Fixing the Spin on Evaluation, Laura C. Leviton
Commentary: From Substance Abuse to Evaluation Misuse: Is There a Way Out?, Sharon F. Rallis
What If...?
Final Thoughts: Nightly News
Scenario 2: Is My Job Done Yet?
Questions to Consider
8. Lessons Learned
Appendix A. The Guiding Principles for Evaluators
Appendix B. The Program Evaluation Standards, Second Edition